Monday, December 2, 2019

Human Variation and Race

     Homeostasis is the body's natural ability to maintain an equilibrium. In cold climates, homeostasis is disturbed as the body's core body temperature can drop significantly and cause hypothermia without a sufficent way of maintaing body heat. Hypothermia begins once the body's core temperature drops below 94 degrees fahrenheit. Once this happens the blood flow begins restricted to vital organs in effort to maintain body heat and as temperature continues to drop, organs begin to shut down. Therefore, in an effort to adapt and survive in such cold climates, humans have developed a variety of both biological and cultural techniques to help maintain their core body temperature.
     As a short-term adaptation, humans developed what is known as the Lewis hunting phenomenon. This is when the blood vessels constrict, preserving body heat by reducing peripheral blood flow. However, to much vasoconstriction can lead to frost bite, so as a result vasodialation occurs, increasing the flow blood flow back to the skin. This process cycles in effort to maintain body heat. As a facultative adaptation, human populations found in colder climates have developed and increased basal metabolic rate allowing to consume and digest larger quantities of fatty and higher calorie foods. This increased basal metabolic rate in turn produces increased body heat as well as helps develop a thicker lining of fat around vital organs to help maintain body heat. As a developmental adaptation, populations in colder climates are typically bulky and large
. Overtime natural selection began favoring people with such a physique as they had less surface area. A decreased surface area allowed for less heat to escape and more heat to be contained which allowed for better survival in these colder climate. This trend is known as Bergmann's Rule and can be seen not just throughout humans, but animals as well. Cold climates favor less surface area. A cultural adaptation that is most obvious for populations found in colder climates is the use of thicker, woolier clothing that covers them from head to toe. In colder climates we see the use of parkas which are essentially long thickly insulated coats that do a tremendous job at keeping the body insulated. In such clothing we see as clothes are typically lined with a dense fur or wool as these are the best at insulating. Here we also see the development of gloves. We also see and increased presence of facial hair in men that helps insulate their face.
     From studying human variation across different evironmental clines, we can best understand the origins of different races and why even though we are the same species, as a whole look very differnt. This helps us better understand the origin of our families. However, this information can most productively show that although our physical features are very different, we are all the same. It just so happens that the only reason we look different is that our ancestors were limited to a singular environment before we had the capability to migrate. There simply has not been enough time since wide spread migration among races began for the majority of the human population to begin to look alike. Humans as a species are simply too wide spread and adaptable accross too many different climates for us to all look the same.
     A similar idea can be shared when using race to understand human variation. While most of the biological variations developed in response to climate, many people from different climates share the same biological responses. For the most part the only real difference amongst races is skin color and the amount of vitamin D they can absorb or the effect of UV rays on their skin. However, as time goes on, and people continue to migrate and mate, these few differences become more widespread and common; in a sense neutral. Even cultural adaptations are shared amongst races as they travel to differnet climates and environments. Using races to understand variations really just helps us understand how different populations adapted to their environment, thus creating this idea of race. IN regards to the cold climate, it makes sense why historically people in northern europe such as russians can be compared to bears as they traditionally appear more bulky and stocky. Cultures that develop in cold weather typically all share similar traits accross their entire culture, especially in regards to tools, clothes, mirgation, etc.

4 comments:

  1. Hey, Jimmy!

    I enjoyed reading your blog post. I, too, wrote about heat, but I focused on high temperatures rather than low ones. It was interesting to note how the body's responses differ for negative feedback, indicating a spike in body temperature versus negative feedback indicating a drop in body temperature. I hadn't heard of the Lewis hunting phenomenon before, and wasn't aware that over-constriction was the cause of frostbite.

    Likewise, I didn't realize that smaller physiques were better equipped to survive in colder climates. I fell victim to the common misconception that larger physiques would remain warmer because fat is dense and acts as a barrier between the veins and the skin, meaning there is a further distance for the low temperature to travel before the veins get the signal to constrict. Interesting. I had no idea. Thank you for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Jimmy,

    I enjoyed going through your blog post! I like how you wrote about cold weather as a environmental stress factor. I ended up writing about high altitudes and how it van negatively affect the survival of human beings. You did a great job talking about body heat in colder temperatures and how the human body reacts to the cold in different ways. I like how you brought up hypothermia, because that is one of the causes of adapting to colder environments. This post is almost perfect, and I say almost because I saw a grammar error. You spelled different as "differnt". Other than that, this post was very informative and very well done.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent opening discussion on the dangers of cold stress. Good explanation on how cold negatively and specifically impacts the body.

    Vasoconstriction/vasodilation (the hunting phenomenon) is actually a facultative response, as it required the turning on/off of systems to cause the capillaries to open and close. and example of an immediate response to cold is shivering.

    Good facultative example, though the hunting phenomenon is another good one. Missing an image for this?

    Good discussion on Bergmann & Allen's rules and how it helps us understand how body shape is an adaptation to temperature stresses.

    Good cultural adaptation.

    I agree that knowledge of our ancestry is useful (and knowledge in general is always useful), but can you identify a way this knowledge can be useful in a concrete way? Can knowledge on adaptations to cold climates have medical implications? Help us develop clothing that retains heat more efficiently? Can we develop new means of home/building construction that might help increase heat retention? How can we actually use this information in an applied fashion?

    "Using races to understand variations really just helps us understand how different populations adapted to their environment, thus creating this idea of race."

    Is that actually using race, or are you just using the adaptive response and layering race over top of it? Can you really use race to explain human variation? Understand that it is perfectly acceptable to answer this question with a "no".

    To answer this question, you first need to explore what race actually is. Race is not based in biology but is a social construct, based in beliefs and preconceptions, and used only to categorize humans into groups based upon external physical features, much like organizing a box of crayons by color. Race does not *cause* adaptations like environmental stress do, and without that causal relationship, you can't use race to explain adaptations. Race has no explanatory value over human variation.

    ReplyDelete